News

Immigrant New Yorkers say the line between the NYPD and ICE is blurring

Immigrant New Yorkers and their elected officials told the City Council that NYPD officers appear to be aiding ICE, as lawmakers weigh bills to close gaps in the city’s sanctuary laws.

Naima Dahir, Jocelyn Atahualpa and Assemblymember Catalina Cruz testify about the NYPD and ICE at a City Council immigration hearing.
From left, Naima Dahir, Jocelyn Atahualpa and Assemblymember Catalina Cruz (D-Queens) testify on ICE and the NYPD at a City Council hearing, Nov. 20, 2026. (Photo: Audrey Kemp/Courier New York)

On the night of Oct. 8, New York City Council Member Carmen De La Rosa (D-Manhattan) stood outside an Upper Manhattan hospital and watched NYPD officers walk federal immigration agents to their cars, just hours after an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent shot Oscar Belgal, 28, in the neck while his 5-year-old son sat in the back seat of his car in Marble Hill.On Friday, she put the question to the department directly.

“Who are you protecting?” De La Rosa asked NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Legal Matters Michael Gerber at a City Council Committee on Immigration hearing. “Are you protecting my community, or are you protecting the ICE officers?”

The exchange captured the tension running through the hearing. The New York Police Department (NYPD) maintains that it never assists federal immigration enforcement. Elected officials and organizers from Corona to Marble Hill described encounters they say tell a different story, and they warned that trust in local police is eroding as ICE arrests climb across the five boroughs.

What did immigrant New Yorkers tell the Council?

Public Advocate Jumaane Williams cited a city audit that found ICE arrested 5,567 people in the New York City area between January 2025 and March 2026—a 71% increase over the same stretch at the end of the Biden administration.

Assemblymember Catalina Cruz (D-Queens) said her office went from responding to “a couple of ICE kidnappings a week” in 2025 to “several ICE kidnappings every single day.”

Cruz testified that on Sept. 4, her staff watched an ICE agent drive into a Queens precinct’s parking lot and walk inside “as if they worked there.” She also pointed to a video from Jackson Heights in which NYPD officers appeared to be guarding ICE agents during an arrest.

“There’s a big difference between saying it and seeing it,” Cruz said.

Jocelyn Atahualpa, an organizer with Queens Neighborhoods United, said ICE vehicles have parked at the 110th and 115th precincts. She also said local crossing guards have asked residents about their immigration status.

Council Member Rita Joseph (D-Brooklyn) said agents who arrested Flatbush father Roberto Lamour on Oct. 3 allegedly identified themselves as NYPD to get inside his home. Council Member Alexa Avilés (D-Brooklyn) noted that public defenders have previously reviewed body-camera footage showing officers assisting with ICE arrests in people’s homes.

How did the NYPD respond?

Gerber pushed back. He said the NYPD has not honored a civil immigration detainer in a decade, and that he personally refused an ICE request on Oct. 8 to help coordinate the agents’ exit from the hospital. When officers moved protesters out of the path of departing ICE vehicles, he said, they were trying to keep people from getting hurt.

“If we just walk away, how does that story end?” Gerber said.

Still, he acknowledged the damage. “I understand the optics piece. I understand the concerns that have been raised,” he said.

Gerber also disclosed that a 2025 internal audit of task-force officers’ communications turned up substantiated violations, with disciplinary charges still pending. He added that a separate Department of Investigation review found a detective who had broken the city’s sanctuary law.

The NYPD did not respond to Courier New York’s request for comment.

Council Member Gale Brewer (D-Manhattan) urged the department to plan for the next confrontation. She suggested assigning officers whom the community already knows to act as mediators at ICE scenes.

“They’re professional and the ICE agents are not,” Brewer said of NYPD officers. “They’re goons, in my opinion.”

What would the ‘Cut Ties with ICE’ bills do?

The hearing also took up the “Cut Ties with ICE” legislative package, which immigrant advocates are pushing to close loopholes in the city’s sanctuary laws.

Two bills sponsored by Committee Chair Elsie Encarnación (D-Manhattan/Bronx) would bar the NYPD (Intro 1077-A) and the Department of Correction (Intro 1078) from holding people past their release date on civil immigration detainers, or from tipping off federal authorities about their release, unless ICE presents a judicial warrant tied to a criminal matter unrelated to immigration enforcement.

Intro 1077-A would also eliminate an existing exception that lets the NYPD hold someone for up to 48 hours. Encarnación said the change would bring city law in line with state court rulings.

The pressure on the jails is mounting. The city’s audit found the Department of Correction received 895 detainer requests from ICE in 2025, a 120% jump from the year before.

The coalition’s package also includes Intro 209, which would let New Yorkers sue when city agencies illegally cooperate with immigration authorities. That bill was not on Friday’s hearing agenda.

Intro 739, sponsored by Council Member Shahana Hanif (D-Brooklyn), would require city agencies and contractors to train staff on the city’s sanctuary protections and publish their plans for complying with them.

The committee also heard Resolution 729, which calls on Albany to pass the Building Up Immigrant Legal Defense (BUILD) Act. The bill, sponsored by Cruz and state Sen. John Liu, would fund grants to expand the number of lawyers available to immigrants facing deportation.

Mayor’s Office of Immigrant Affairs Commissioner Faiza Ali said the Mamdani administration supports “the spirit of the legislation” and that the city’s Law Department is reviewing the detainer bills. Gerber said the NYPD supports them as well.

What happens next?

For Council Member Shanel Thomas-Henry (D-Queens), whose district includes Corona, the stakes are personal. She said she often drops her children off at school only to respond to ICE activity blocks away.

“Fear will not have the final say in our communities,” she said.

Hours after the hearing, advocates with the ICE Out! NYC coalition rallied on the steps of City Hall to push the Council to pass the “Cut Ties with ICE” package.

Joseph, who immigrated from Haiti as a child and taught in city public schools for more than 20 years, told the crowd that ICE is arresting people at routine check-ins, leaving children to wonder whether their parents will be home after school.

“A child who’s afraid cannot learn,” Joseph said.

She argued that the city’s sanctuary status means little if agencies can still work around it.

“We are a sanctuary city. Our laws say it, but laws only matter if they’re enforced, and laws with loopholes don’t protect anyone,” Joseph said. “To my colleagues, let’s not wait. Let’s pass this full package, all three bills, as soon as possible.”

Keep Courier New York free for everyone

If you found this story useful, would you consider supporting Courier New York?

Every day, our team works to provide New Yorkers with free, fact-based reporting about the issues, policies, and decisions shaping life across the state. We believe everyone deserves access to trustworthy local news—not just those who can afford a subscription.

That's why you'll never hit a paywall here (though we may ask you to sign up for our newsletter). But keeping our journalism free depends on readers who believe informed communities are worth investing in.

If our reporting has helped you better understand what's happening in New York, please consider making a donation today. Every contribution helps us continue reporting, informing, and serving communities across the state.

Audrey Kemp
Audrey Kemp Political Correspondent
Support our team

Categories: ,

Authors

  • Audrey Kemp is the political correspondent for Courier New York. Based in Brooklyn, she covers the issues that matter to everyday New Yorkers, including immigration, labor, housing, and healthcare. A graduate of UC Irvine, where she studied literary journalism, Audrey is passionate about telling stories that capture how policy shapes daily life.

    She has covered a range of beats over her career, including corporate social responsibility at Adweek and The Drum, and got her start as a music journalist in Los Angeles.

    A native of Southern California and the child of immigrants, Audrey feels a deep tether to New York and has made it her mission to pour into the communities that call it home.

    Have a story tip? Reach Audrey at audrey@couriernewsroom.com. For local reporting that connects the dots, from policy to people, sign up for her free newsletter here.