Food & Drink

What makes this Westchester bakery the best for Thanksgiving pies

Galloway’s Bakery, which started as a luncheonette in Bronxville before segueing to a spot in Hartsdale, takes pride in keeping to its origins.

Galloway's Bakery owners
Shannon Galloway, left, with her parents, Bob and Patti, at Galloway's Bakery in Scarsdale, a family-owned spot since 1956 that is known for their pies. (Peter Carr/The Journal News via Reuters Connect)

Reporting by Jeanne Muchnick, Rockland/Westchester Journal News

It’s the sights, smells, tastes and sense of nostalgia that make Galloway’s Bakery in Scarsdale special. This third-generation bakery, which dates to the late 1940s and is run by the founder’s granddaughter, Shannon Galloway, is pretty much exactly as it’s always been, which Galloway said is key to its success. (For the record, the website says 1956, but Galloway said she found evidence it was earlier.)

“We’re plain and simple,” she said. “Everything is made by hand. And because we’ve never branched out, we’ve stuck to what we do best.” That means pies — lots of them, from cherry to coconut to chocolate cream — alongside cakes, cookies, doughnuts, breads, buns and Danish rings.

The bakery, which started as a luncheonette in Bronxville before segueing to a spot in Hartsdale, takes pride in keeping to its origins. Ads from The Bronxville Reporter dating to 1952, in fact, list the exact pies that are sold now, among them deep dish apple, chocolate cream and lemon meringue.

Galloway's bakery
A slice of chocolate cream pie at Galloway’s Bakery in Scarsdale. (Peter Carr/The Journal News via Reuters Connect)

All recipes are exactly the same as what existed when Galloway’s grandfather, Fred, started the business with wife Marjorie. The two, who were open six days a week, found that their pies by the slice sold so well, they consistently got inquiries for whole pies. So they transitioned to a bakery when they moved to Hartsdale in 1956.

After relocating to Scarsdale in 1962 — at the time the spot also sold specialty items like homemade jams — they truncated their hours to Friday, Saturday and Sunday. Galloway said the reasoning was partly due to the location.

“We weren’t downtown,” she said. “The street was less trafficked so it made sense that if you’re coming here, you’re coming here for a reason.”

Pies are the focus at Galloway’s

That reason, for more than 60 years, has been pies. But the draw is also the bakery’s traditional breads, doughnuts, layer cakes and cookies. Plus, its homespun charm, much of which Galloway credits to her parents, Bob and Patti (Bob is Fred’s son), who took over in the mid 1970s and molded the business into what it is today: a cozy spot built on personal service and lasting relationships with customers, many of whom have become friends.

The vintage décor is another plus, with wood shelves that haven’t changed since the ’70s and string dispensers hanging from the ceiling that date to the ’60s.

That homey feeling — along with its oven-fresh goodies — have made Galloway’s a holiday tradition. Come Thanksgiving, the busiest time, it has become an annual ritual to lineup before they open their doors at 7 a.m. to ensure you get the pie — or pies — of your choice.

“Not only are we generational,” said Galloway — she took over ownership in 2017 after her parents retired — “but so are our customers.”

Galloway's bakery
Galloway’s Bakery in Scarsdale, a family-owned spot since 1956, is known for their pies. (Peter Carr/The Journal News via Reuters Connect)

Families have made it their yearly pilgrimage, she said, to stand outside, chitchat and wait for their turn in the bakery, often making friends in line or seeing the same faces that also come yearly. Inside the narrow storefront, pies are boxed and labeled on shelves for easy grab-and-go access. (Just be aware, it’s cash or check only.)

As a pie holiday with classic favorites, Thanksgiving is the one time of the year you can’t order pies in advance. Nor can you get regular pies: only deep dish are available. Galloway’s bakers (that includes Shannon who’s up and at it at 2 a.m.) make the basics that day: apple, apple crumb, pumpkin, pecan, mince, along with banana cream, chocolate cream and coconut cream.

All pies are 9 inches and serve approximately 10.

This is also the only time of year there’s a limited amount of muffins, cookies, breads, dinner rolls and layer cakes, so if you want those, too, it’s best to come early and join the line.

Galloway said they always overbake but by two or three on the afternoon of Thanksgiving Eve they usually sell out of something, often apple or apple crumb. If you prefer pumpkin, pecan or a cream pie, she said you can generally come midday and find what you need (though there are no guarantees).

Worth noting: This being an old-fashioned spot that sticks to its traditional beginnings means you won’t find anything gluten-free. It’s also not a nut/seed-free facility.

Family is at the heart of Galloway’s Bakery

Baking pies is not something Galloway originally thought she’d be doing, but carrying on the traditions of her family is something she cherishes.

“I grew up with this shop basically as my sibling,” she said. So when her dad started thinking about leaving the business, she left her job in the financial world to step in, learning from him in the same prep area he was trained in by his father, Fred.

Galloway's Bakery owners
Shannon Galloway, left, with her parents, Bob and Patti, at Galloway’s Bakery in Scarsdale, a family-owned spot since 1956 that is known for their pies. (Peter Carr/The Journal News via Reuters Connect)

She said continuing her family’s legacy means more than words can express.

“Over the years, employees and customers have become an extension of our family. I never take for granted that our products find their way onto our customers’ tables during life’s happiest celebrations, as well as during its most difficult moments.

“To know that products we make with our hands and hearts can be part of those memories is an honor and a privilege. It’s one of the many reasons carrying on this family tradition means so much to me,” said Galloway.

“People say you can’t go home again but you can, at Galloway’s,” she added. “People walk in here who haven’t been in 20 years and always comment on how everything is the same. The smells, the tastes, the look are all the same and there’s comfort in that.”

If you go

Address: 69 Harney Road, Scarsdale, 914-725-4074, gallowaysbakery.com.

Hours: 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. Friday and Saturday; to 3 p.m. Sunday.

Thanksgiving hours: 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Thanksgiving Eve; from 8 a.m. to noon Thanksgiving Day.

Pay the old-fashioned way: Cash or check only with an ATM on premises.

Prices: $36 to $37 for deep dish pies (regular pies on other days are $25 to $26).

Good to know for Thanksgiving: There’s no ordering ahead. Stand in line for first dibs on your favorites. Galloway said if you’re leaning towards pecan or pumpkin, you can generally come around mid-day and avoid the line. Pies do sell out so there’s no guarantee.

Holiday tip: They’re also open Christmas Eve and the day before, though best to order in advance.

Hungry for more intel? Sign up for my free weekly newsletter, which often includes behind-the-scenes info I don’t always share in my stories at profile.lohud.com/newsletters/manage.

Jeanne Muchnick covers food and dining. Click here for her most recent articles and follow her latest dining adventures on Instagram @jeannemuchnick or via the lohudfood newsletter.

This article originally appeared on Rockland/Westchester Journal News.

Related: 6 surprising spots for Thanksgiving pies in Westchester, Rockland